A planning application for houses on Falmouth Golf Course land has sparked concerns among councillors about further development on the site. One councillor described it as a ‘Trojan horse’ application. The golf club’s owner, David Hughes, applied to build two houses on land next to 20 recently built homes. The golf course had to be altered to create safer holes away from the road. Although a different developer built the houses, they were seen as completing the neighbouring estate.
Cornwall Council’s planning department recommended approval, stating that the benefits of the scheme, including additional housing and an affordable housing contribution, outweighed the disadvantages. However, local residents and councillors expressed their opposition to the development. They argued that the proposed houses would be unsightly, out of character, and have a negative impact on the amenities of the golf club and the area of outstanding natural beauty (AONB) in which they live.
The Falmouth Town Council, which voted against the development, highlighted the loss of green space in the town in recent years. They referred to their Neighbourhood Development Plan, which states that development of open spaces with high value will not be supported. They also emphasized the importance of preserving sports facilities and wildlife habitats. The proposed development would result in the loss of 35 meters of Cornish hedge, which the plan states should be reinstated elsewhere.
The planning agent for the applicant argued that the proposed houses would not impair the golfing facility as the western part of the site was never part of the golf course. They also stated that the development would preserve the AONB by retaining and adding trees, maintaining Cornish hedgerows, and creating green amenity areas. The agent highlighted the need for housing in the area and the multiple public benefits of the development, including improved visibility at a road junction and a financial contribution towards affordable housing.
Despite these arguments, the planning committee unanimously refused the application due to concerns about the AONB and the loss of green space. Councillors expressed fears that approving this development could open the door to further development in the future. They emphasized the importance of AONB policies and the need to draw a line to prevent further development in areas of outstanding natural beauty.
The controversy surrounding the housing development on Falmouth Golf Course reflects the ongoing debate about balancing the need for housing with the preservation of green spaces and natural beauty. It highlights the concerns of local residents and councillors about the impact of development on the character and amenities of their town. The decision to refuse the application demonstrates the council’s commitment to protecting the AONB and preserving green spaces for the enjoyment of current and future generations.