World Rugby is poised to implement a trial for a new red card process that has the potential to eradicate the influence of mitigating factors on subsequent bans. The primary aim of this initiative is to introduce greater consistency in bans while prioritising the welfare of players. Under the new process, any foul play will result in an automatic two-week ban, with aggravated foul play, such as a no-arms tackle, warranting an automatic four-week ban. The new system will not consider any mitigating factors when imposing these automatic sanctions. If implemented, it is estimated that around 70% of red cards issued in 2024 would have resulted in automatic sanctions.
However, in more serious incidents, a disciplinary committee will still be involved in determining the appropriate sanction, similar to the current system in place. Furthermore, trials will be conducted to explore the possibility of allowing a red-carded player to be replaced by another player after 20 minutes, an idea that has already been tested in the southern hemisphere. Of particular interest, current trials with the 20-minute red card rule have demonstrated a significant decrease in the number of red cards issued, as well as a 37% reduction in tackle-related injuries.
According to World Rugby chairman Sir Bill Beaumont, the streamlined off-field sanction process was developed based on feedback received at the Shape of the Game conference. The feedback indicated a need for simplifying the rugby disciplinary process to make it more understandable for players and fans, while still upholding welfare and game integrity imperatives. Notably, this trial upholds a commitment to maintaining consistency and agility, while reducing the influence of legalities in the disciplinary process.
The trials will take place during competitions such as the U20 World Championships. In addition to the new red card process, World Rugby will also be trialling five potential law changes. These include shot clock amendments, increased protection for the scrum-half at the base of the scrum, ruck, and maul, the ability to mark the ball inside the 22m line from a restart, playing the ball after the maul has been stopped once, and allowing play to continue at a lineout if the ball is not thrown straight.
These initiatives come in the wake of World Rugby’s announcement of three law changes, which include amendments to the free kick and ‘Dupont’s law’, as well as the banning of the crocodile roll. With the introduction of these trials and potential law changes, World Rugby is clearly demonstrating a proactive approach to enhancing the safety and fairness of the sport.
For the latest rugby news, you can access the digital edition of Rugby World on your tablet or subscribe to the print edition for doorstep delivery. Stay tuned for the outcome of these trials and anticipate potential changes that could shape the future of rugby.