Rugby has unquestionably undergone considerable evolution over time, presenting a considerable challenge when comparing players across different eras. This challenge is similarly faced in other sports. It is quite difficult to envision how renowned players from the past would perform in today’s game. A prime example is the renowned Don Bradman, whose Test match batting average of 99.94 would have confronted a barrage of fast bowlers targeting the batsman’s head, rather than the wicket.
In the early days of rugby, fly-halves such as Barry John and Ian Robertson were not particularly recognized for their tackling abilities. John once famously conveyed to his forwards, “I don’t tackle – that’s your job.” This approach was widespread in an era where fly-halves were not expected to partake in the physical aspects of the game. However, the emergence of players like Johnny Wilkinson led to a shift in this mindset, highlighting the significance of tackling for fly-halves.
With this context in mind, we can consider the case of Finn Russell. Despite being a lightly built fly-half, Russell has exhibited his fair share of tackling skills, albeit in a more calculated and precise manner, as opposed to the aggressive style seen in players like Wilkinson. His ability to adapt to the changing demands of the game is undeniably impressive.
When assessing how Russell compares to his Scotland predecessors, it is impossible to disregard the contributions of past fly-halves such as Angus Cameron, Gordon Waddell, Davie Chisholm, and Eck Hastie. Each of these players brought their own distinctive style to the position, leaving an enduring impact on Scottish rugby. Looking ahead to more recent history, names such as John Rutherford and Gregor Townsend come to mind as formidable successors to the fly-half position.
Rutherford, renowned for his exceptional speed and tactical kicking, was a dominant force during the later years of the amateur game. Conversely, Townsend’s introduction to the scene at the tender age of 18 made a profound impression, highlighting his inherently gifted ability to read the game and execute interception tries. Both players injected their own panache and finesse into the position, leaving an indelible mark on Scottish rugby.
In the modern game, where power-driven tactics hold sway, Russell has displayed a remarkable ability to adapt and excel. While not as quick as Rutherford or Townsend, Russell has elevated his game, evolving into a tactically astute player with a talent for achieving results in confined spaces. His development as a player reflects the evolving nature of the game itself.
Ultimately, attempting to compare players from different eras is an exercise in futility. Each player brings their own array of skills and attributes to the position, making definitive rankings impossible. Instead, we can appreciate the distinct contributions of each player and acknowledge their impact on the sport.
Rugby continues to evolve, and as it does, players like Finn Russell will continue to shape the game in their own unique manner. Whilst comparisons to past greats may endure, it is vital to recognise the distinctive qualities that each player brings to the table, ultimately enriching the sport for years to come.