Gareth Southgate’s tenure as England manager has been truly transformative, leading the Three Lions to significant accomplishments and re-establishing them as a continental power. However, despite this progress, England’s search for their first major trophy since the 1966 World Cup continues.
During England’s recent Euro 2024 campaign, Southgate’s unwavering support for Harry Kane was apparent, ultimately contributing to the team’s defeat in the final against Spain. Despite Kane’s difficulties, Southgate continued to start him, despite indications that he was not at his peak physical condition. This decision, coupled with a history of inaction during critical moments, highlights Southgate’s inability to make decisive strategic changes when necessary.
Throughout the tournament, England’s performances raised concerns, with narrow escapes against Slovakia and Switzerland, as well as subpar showings in the group stage. Despite possessing a squad of exceptional talent, including Jude Bellingham and Phil Foden, Southgate failed to fully harness their potential.
With England once again returning without a major tournament victory, it is clear that while Southgate has brought the team a long way, he may have reached the limit of his capabilities as a coach.
The English FA’s unwavering support for Southgate’s continued leadership may not be the most advantageous path to England’s future success. While acknowledging Southgate’s positive contributions, it is crucial to recognize that England requires a coach who can make tactical decisions at crucial moments, enhance the team’s performance, and maximize the potential of their talented players.
While the English FA may be inclined to retain Southgate due to the relative tranquillity he brings, the ultimate goal of securing victory in major tournaments may necessitate a different approach.
As Spain celebrates their European Championship victory, England stands at a crossroads. It may be time for the English FA to reassess their options and embrace a new direction that will propel the team towards the success they have long sought.